Mrs. Tracie Glazer
Course Description |
The AED 690 capstone course will provide art education students with the opportunity to draw from and demonstrate synthesis of their total experience in the graduate program. Students will reflect on their teaching and make connections between theory and practice in relation to current trends, concepts, and contemporary issues in art education. More specifically, this course will investigate the movement from modernity to postmodernism and the inclusion of visual culture in the art curriculum. In addition, student will explore their roles as professionals in the field of art education.
In this course students will conduct independent inquiry and prepare, both artistic as well as a written, projects in which problems of personal and professional significance are investigated and reported. The written capstone project is to be composed of research conducted by the student for the purpose of demonstrating knowledge and understanding of research methods in art education, and knowledge of issues and developments in the field of art education. Students who plan to work with human subjects in their research study must abide by the rules and practices established for Nazareth College.
The content of this course seeks to meet the claims of student learning cited by Nazareth College for the Teacher Education Accreditation Council (TEAC), the Department of Art, the College of Arts and Sciences (CAS) and the National Art Education Association (NAEA).
This course seeks to align itself with the tenets of student learning cited by Nazareth College for the Teacher Education Accreditation Council (TEAC).
Teachers prepared at Nazareth College:
TEAC #1: demonstrate the knowledge to be successful educators.
TEAC #2: design and implement effective instruction for diverse learners in various settings.
TEAC #3: reflect critically on their practice and the profession.
Student Learning Outcomes
The purpose of this course is to provide the opportunity for the synthesis of the graduate program by:
Students will be expected to:
Use technology, basic visual communication skills, and oral skills to present and defend their research on a professional level. Work towards developing their skills and expertise in the area of art education research. Document their learning, development, research and artistic processes in a course sourcebook.
Policy for Written Work and Research
Students will be expected to use the American Psychological Association (APA) Manual (6th ed.) as a guideline for all written work. Please refer to the Nazareth College Graduate Students Handbook for policies on academic integrity for more information on issues including, but not limited to, plagiarism. Students will be expected to evaluate their own writing capabilities and if necessary, seek help (e.g. Writing Center).
Students with Special Needs
Students with documented disabilities are asked to share with the instructor, in confidence, information regarding specific modifications.
Course Requirements:
1. Professionalism
Class attendance and class participation including discussion, presentations, and written assignments are required. Please see the attached AED professional disposition forms for further elaboration. Students will be expected to use Moodle for communication and retrieving specific reading assignments. Please see Computer Services for assistance with this system. Note: Naz email accounts can be forwarded to other email accounts. See ITS website. NO LATE ASSIGNMENTS WILL BE ACCEPTED*
TEAC claim of student learning #3.
Art Department goal #6, CAS Goal #7; NAEA XV
*The instructor may deem that special circumstances indicate an exception to this policy.
2. Analysis Papers and Questions on Readings
For each reading assignment, students will submit a one-page analysis, which includes at least two thoughtful questions pertaining to each of the assigned readings. This analysis should not be a basic summary or retell, but should rather provide synthesis and analysis of the articles assigned. Questions should be submitted electronically via Moodle 2 days prior to class (by 7 pm). The purpose of these papers and questions are to extend thinking on issues in the field, specifically as it refers to the connections between theory and practice as an artist/teacher, and the social, political, and historical influences on art education. No late papers/questions will be accepted. You will also be required to bring a hard copy of the analysis to class for grading. No grade will be given without the submission of this hardcopy.
TEAC claim of student learning #1, #2, #3
Art Department goals #2, #6, #7; CAS Goal #2,5,6, 7; NAEA XII, XVI, XIX
3. Artistic Paradigms in Art
Students will be expected to work both in class and outside class to create a piece of art that exemplifies an artistic paradigm.
Students will present:
TEAC claim of student learning #1
Art Department goals #2, #9; CAS Goals #3,4, 5; NAEA XI, XII, XV, XVI
4. Capstone Research Project
Students will work individually or collaboratively to investigate a relevant and significant question in the field of art education aimed toward strengthening their beliefs through critical reflection. This paper allows students to demonstrate their capabilities, as a graduate student, by allowing them to bridge theory with practice within an arts advocacy criteria framework and project. It is very important that students choose a topic that is personally meaningful and that will be useful for them in their future work (something that will impact your teaching and learning in a positive way). For the purpose of the Capstone Research Project, research applies to any systematic and organized effort to investigate a specific problem or issues. Generally the researcher must: (1) Know what she or he wants to study; (2) Gather information about what has occurred and was written in the past; (3) Define a methodology by which the problem can be studied; (4) Collect data from appropriate sources; and (5) Analyze, interpret, draw conclusions and make recommendations on the basis of the findings.
It is expected that your work will exhibit a breadth and depth of knowledge and a significant level of research. The written thesis may build on work done in previous courses, however, you must produce a significant amount of new work. No page requirements have been set for the final report, but the student will have difficulty meeting substantive requirements if the presentation is too brief. It is suggested that a minimum requirement for the thesis is at least 10-20 pages of your own writing.
The Capstone Research project may employ qualitative, quantitative or mixed-method research methods on a topic or problem directly related to art education. This could include a phenomenological or action research study or students in an art class context/ an analysis of a premise or construct traced through the literature of art education; a survey or attitudes, beliefs, or practices conducted among arts education professionals; or the preparation and field testing of a curricular module.
The final report should reflect an understanding of the relevant literature; knowledge of the area investigated; skill in conducting the study; ability to analyze data and to apply knowledge and theory; and should report conclusions and recommendations in a professional, coherent, logical, and persuasive manner.
Several drafts and rewrites are often needed before the report is ready for final submission. It is the students responsibility not the instructors to ensure the spelling, syntax, structure and other aspects of the paper project are correct. To avoid the loss of time that can occur if a poorly prepared paper is submitted, it is wise to have a secondary reader and/or editor. These self-selected and organized individuals can read your paper project for content, technical and other errors before it is submitted to the instructor.
The use of digital media in the final form of the presentation/defense is encouraged and can be negotiated with the course instructor.
TEAC claims of student learning #1, #2, #3
Art Department goals #1, #2, #5, #6, #7; CAS Goals #1, 23, 5,6, 7
NAEA IX, XI,XII, XV, XVI, XVII, XIX
5. Art Exhibit
Art Education students will participate fully in the graduate art exhibition to be held in the Spring of 2012. Reception: TBD
TEAC claim of student learning #1, #3
Art Department Goals #4, #5, #6; CAS Goals #3, 4; NAEA I, XII, XVI, XVIII
6. Professional Portfolio
Students will create a professional portfolio (traditional and electronic) to demonstrate competence as educators in their field. The portfolio will serve as evidence of their knowledge and intellectual growth as the result of their Masters Degree Program.
TEAC claim of student learning #1, #2, #3
Art Department Goals #2, #5, #6, #7, #8, #9; CAS #2,3,6; NAEA XI,XII, XIX
7. Personal Artwork in Response to Graduate Studies
Students will create a series of artworks (at least 2-3) to demonstrate their competence as artists in the field. These artworks will serve as evidence of a students knowledge, artistic, and aesthetic growth as the result of their Undergraduate and Masters Degree Programs.
At least one of these artworks should be considered for inclusion in the graduate exhibition.
By the end of the course students will present:
TEAC claim of student learning #1
Art Department goals #2, #9; CAS Goals #3,4, 5; NAEA XI, XII, XV, XVI
Any student failing to have all course requirements in by the end of the course will have her/his name removed from the graduation list, unless there has been a prior agreement made (in writing) with the instructor and program director.
|
Grading Matrix
A 95-100% A- 94-90
B+ 89-87 B 86-84
B- 83-80 C+ 79-77
C 76-74 C- 73-70
F
Art Education Program Crosswalk | |||
Teachers prepared at Nazareth College: | |||
TEAC Claims (2010) | TC #1:demonstrate the knowledge to be successful educators | TC #2:design and implement effective instruction for diverse learners in various settings | TC #3:reflect critically on their practice and the profession |
College of Arts & Sciences Teaching & Learning Goals (CAS) | CAS #1: [will] attain a disciplinary perspective in the liberal arts and sciences: Define the content, the language, the disciplines mode of inquiry and the research methods of the visual arts. CAS #2: [will] develop creative, analytical, quantitative, critical thinking, and problem-solving abilities. CAS #3: [will] communicate effectively through critical reading, writing, and oral presentation skills. CAS #4: [will] develop and express an aethestic sensibility. CAS #5: [will] inspire and be inspired by a passion for intellectual engagement with people and ideas. | CAS #6: [will] be culturally competent and civically engaged global citizens. | CAS #7: [will] be challenged to articulate and live out consistent and responsible ethical beliefs. |
Art Department Objectives | AD #1: Develop visual thinkers; increase awareness and skills of observation. AD #2: Articulate idea development and awareness of sources. AD #3: Explore the elements and principles of design. AD #4: Develop visual strategies and problem-solving skills. AD #5: Gain competency in techniques introduced. AD #9: Use specific media and processes as a means of developing personal aesthetic. | AD #7: Broaden knowledge of western and non-western art forms, historical and contemporary. | AD #6: Develop professional presentation skills and attitudes. AD #8: Develop vocabulary for critical evaluation of works of art. |
NAEA Standards & Skills for Art Teachers (NASAD basis) | NAEA I : have a throrough understanding of the content of art. NAEA XI : are well-versed in pedagogy. | NAEA II : make informed selection of instructional content. NAEA III : have a comprehensive knowledge of student characteristics, abilities, and learning styles. NAEA V: are able to use a knowledge of students to plan appropriate instruction. NAEA VI: develop curriculum reflective of the goals and purposes of art education. NAEA VII: develop curriculum reflective of an understanding of the breadth, the depth, and the purposes of art. NAEA VIII: develop curriculum inclusive of the goals, values, and purposes of education, the community, and society. NAEA IX: are able to affect student learning in the content of art. NAEA X: are able to create effective instructional environments conducive to student learning. NAEA XIV: conduct meaningful and appropriate assessments of student learning. | NAEA XII: inquire into their own practices and the nature of art teaching. NAEA XV : systematically reflect upon their own teaching practice. As students of teaching, they recognize that they will gain expertise with experience and will continuously improve their efforts to teach effectively. NAEA XVI: deal with broader issues in the school setting beyond concern for individual students. At times, they may need to assess the entire art program within the school or district setting. NAEA XVIII: recognize their responsibilities to the schools and the community. NAEA XIX: contribute to the growth of the profession. |
Middle States Significant Learning Outcomes (MS) |
| ||
2011 S. Elliott | |||
Art Education Programs
Statement on Professionalism and Assessment Processes
Entering a professional program shifts the expectations of a student/teacher candidate significantlyyou must begin to demonstrate the qualities not only of a capable student, but of a competent professional as well. As a School of Education faculty, we are obliged to evaluate your readiness to enter the teaching profession on many levels, including knowledge, skills and dispositions. As your mentors and future colleagues, we are committed to ensuring your readiness to take on the profound responsibility of educating youth in our community.
The attached document was developed by the Art Education Program faculty to evaluate a set of behaviors essential to developing professionals. The use of this assessment document is to identify behaviors that may hinder a teacher candidate from developing into a strong, committed and caring professional, and to support the candidate in addressing these issues.
The document will be used by Art Education faculty in the following ways:
Professional Dispositions Assessment (PDA) Form
Candidate Name: _ SEM:Year:Soph. Jr. Sr. Graduate
Instructor Name and Signature:Course:
Commitment to Professionalism & Ethical Behavior | |
Demonstrates maturity and responsibility in meeting commitments by: *being punctual & prepared for classes and meetings *turning in assignments on time *communicating clearly about conflicts, issues or confusions that arise *obtaining notes, handouts, viewing multimedia, etc. when absent from class | |
Maintains a positive attitude toward professional responsibilities, and embraces new challenges and opportunities for growth in the profession. | |
Reflects on own performance and abilities; solicits, accepts, receives and integrates feedback from others. | |
Maintains trust, honesty, and tact in communications and interactions with others; uses a variety of communication modes (verbal, written, electronic, non-verbal) effectively and professionally. | |
Maintains appropriate professional relationships with PreK-12 students, and protects confidentiality of student information. | |
Displays an appearance/demeanor that is appropriate to professional experiences (field experiences, presentations, school visits, etc.) | |
Commitment to Life Long Learning | |
Takes the initiative to seek out resources (e.g., community, family, research-based) and information that will support professional growth. | |
Commitment to All Learners | |
Broadens knowledge of students backgrounds, cultures, families, interests, aptitudes and attitudes; uses these in developing and implementing effective professional learning relationships, curricula, and accommodations/adaptations. | |
Commitment to Collaboration | |
Shows commitment to collaborating with other professionals, with community members, and with classmates. | |
Health & Safety of Others/Self | |
Uses appropriate strategies when responding to safety, emotional or emergency situations. | |
Other Issues | |
Capstone Thesis Proposal Checklist
Methods: Should explain how you will pursue your research: Will you conduct interviews/focus groups? Will you design and implement a survey? Design a project or curricular unit? Do a statistical analysis? Conduct an extensive literature review and analysis?, etc
Scope of Project: Should explain, based on a preliminary review of the literature, what some of the main topics you plan to explore are, how many pages will be devoted to the literature review, analysis, and to a curricular project if you choose to do one.
Timeframe and Concept Map of Project: Should explain your timeframe for completing your project: when you plan to complete each portion of the project and submit it by, etc You also will need to supply a concept map of the project. This can be inserted as a figure/table if you so choose.
Avoid Grammatical Errors: Refer to Nazareth Colleges expected writing conventions, the writing center on campus and make sure to avoid commonly made mistakes! If you need help with writing, the Writing Center is available to assist with all aspects of the writing process from focusing your ideas to organizing your thesis to format and documentation questions. The Writing Center has hours during the day and in the evenings by appointment only. Appointments are limited to 30 minutes only. To make an appointment, call 389-2636
Formatting: Be sure the title of thesis matches proposal form, APA (6th edition) style has been consistently and correctly used, and that the length of your proposal is at least three pages with the concept map.
Reference List: A working reference list should include at least five references in your paper and in a reference list at the end of your proposal no more than half your sources can be Web-based. Make sure that you use APA formatting.
Proposal Draft with Proposal Form is Due to Directing Instructor:
Revised Draft Due to Directing Instructor: . Be aware that you may need to submit multiple drafts!!!
Proposal Deadline for Acceptance: . Again, you should be aware that proposals submitted late will negatively impact your Capstone grade; students who submit the proposal or any course work late are not entitled to the same final grade as students who meet all deadlines.
4245 East Avenue, Rochester, NY 14618
Masters of Science in Art Education
AED 690: Capstone Proposal
Student Name:
Student e-mail:
Capstone Thesis Title:
Directing Instructor:
Secondary Reader:
Anticipated Graduation Date:
Attach this form to your typed thesis proposal. Your proposal must include a detailed description of your subject matter, the methodology and general approach, details such as length and style, a schedule/timeframe for completion, a concept map, and an initial list of references related to your subject. Any significant changes in the project need to be identified and agreed to by the student and instructor with a copy of the changes signed by both parties. You should use the following time frame/checklist to guide you:
Please sign and date:
Student Signature:Date:
Secondary Readers Signature:Date:
Directing Instructors Signature:Date:
*Nazareth College reserves the right to change course requirements at any time during the students program.
Final Capstone/Thesis Report Checklist